CommonCoreOntologies/documentation/diff-reports-previous-version/AgentOntology.md

Ontology comparison

Left

• Ontology IRI: http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/AgentOntology
• Version IRI: http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/2024-02-14/AgentOntology
• Loaded from: file:/Users/markjensen/Documents/GitHub/CommonCoreOntologies/src/cco-modules/old/AgentOntology.ttl

Right

• Ontology IRI: http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/AgentOntology
• Version IRI: http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Mid/2024-02-14/AgentOntology
• Loaded from: file:/Users/markjensen/Documents/GitHub/CommonCoreOntologies/src/cco-modules/AgentOntology.ttl

Ontology imports

Ontology annotations

Removed

• license BSD-3-Clause

Added

• license "BSD 3-Clause: https://github.com/CommonCoreOntology/CommonCoreOntologies/blob/master/LICENSE"@en

• rights "CUBRC Inc., see full license."@en

Action Permission http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/ActionPermission

Removed

• Action Permission definition "An Action Regulation that permits some Act."@en

Added

• Action Permission definition "A Process Regulation that permits some Process."@en

Action Prohibition http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/ActionProhibition

Removed

• Action Prohibition label "Action Prohibition"@en

• Action Prohibition definition "An Action Regulation that prohibits some Act."@en

Added

• Action Prohibition label "Process Prohibition"@en

• Action Prohibition definition "A Process Regulation that prohibits some Process."@en

Action Regulation http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/ActionRegulation

Removed

• Action Regulation label "Action Regulation"@en

• Action Regulation definition "A Directive Information Content Entity that prescribes an Act as required, prohibited, or permitted, and is the output of an Act which realizes some Authority Role."@en

Added

• Action Regulation label "Process Regulation"@en

• Action Regulation elucidation "Although regulations often regulate processes which involve agents--as the regulating or regulated participant--it is unclear how causally active an agents need to be in those regulated processes. For example, it is not clear how causally active a human agent is in the process of a traffic light regulating the motion of a self-driving vehicle."@en

• Action Regulation definition "A Directive Information Content Entity that prescribes an Process as required, prohibited, or permitted, and is the output of an Process which realizes some Authority Role."@en

Action Requirement http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/ActionRequirement

Removed

• Action Requirement label "Action Requirement"@en

• Action Requirement definition "An Action Regulation that requires some Act."@en

Added

• Action Requirement definition "A Process Regulation that requires some Process."@en

• Action Requirement label "Process Requirement"@en

Authority Role http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/AuthorityRole

Removed

• Authority Role definition "A Role that is realized by Acts which create, modify, transfer, or eliminate Action Regulations or other Authority Roles, and inheres in an Agent in virtue of collective acceptance of that Agent's ability to issue binding directives."@en

Added

• Authority Role definition "A Role that is realized by Processes which create, modify, transfer, or eliminate Process Regulations or other Authority Roles, and inheres in an Agent in virtue of collective acceptance of that Agent's ability to issue binding directives."@en

Domain of a Country http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Country

Removed

• Domain of a Country editorialNote "'Country' is an unclear term. Does it refer to the people, the government, the site, or the material in the site? Furthermore, what is properly referred to as a 'Country' is highly dependent on the classification practices of the international community. For example: The United Kingdom is a sovereign country that has Wales, a non-sovereign Country, as a member. Vatican City is a sovereign country that is landlocked by a city: Rome, Italy. Puerto Rico is not a county (it's a territory) but has a government, a distinct culture, and so on. Thus, here we do not definine 'Country' but instead define 'Domain of a Country'."@en

Added

• Domain of a Country editorialNote "'Country' is an unclear term. Does it refer to the people, the government, the site, or the material in the site? Furthermore, what is properly referred to as a 'Country' is highly dependent on the classification practices of the international community. For example: The United Kingdom is a sovereign country that has Wales, a non-sovereign Country, as a member. Vatican City is a sovereign country that is landlocked by a city: Rome, Italy. Puerto Rico is not a country (it's a territory) but has a government, a distinct culture, and so on. Thus, here we do not definine 'Country' but instead define 'Domain of a Country'."@en

Educational Organization http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/EducationalOrganization

Removed

• Educational Organization definition "An Organization whose purpose is to provide training or otherwise facilitate learning or the acquisition of knowledge, Skills, values, beliefs, or habits."@en

Added

• Educational Organization definition "An Organization whose primary purpose is to provide training or otherwise facilitate learning or the acquisition of knowledge, Skills, values, beliefs, or habits."@en

Enemy http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/Enemy

Removed

• Enemy label "Enemy"@en

Added

• Enemy label "Enemy Person"@en

Government Organization http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/GovernmentAgency

Removed

• Government Organization definition "An Organization that is part of a Government and is responsible for the oversight and administration of specific governmental functions."@en

Added

• Government Organization definition "An Organization that is part of a Government and is responsible for the oversight or administration of specific governmental functions."@en

Permanent Resident http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/PermanentResident

Removed

• Permanent Resident definition "A person with a Permanent Residence Role."@en

Added

• Permanent Resident definition "A person with a Permanent Resident Role."@en

has familial relationship to http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/has_familial_relationship_to

Added

• Symmetric: has familial relationship to

has subordinate role http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/has_subordinate_role

Removed

• has subordinate role definition "For all x,y,t: x has subordinate role y at t iff: x is an instance of bfo:BFO_0000023 (Role) at time t, and y is an instance of bfo:BFO_0000023 (Role) at time t, and there is some z such that x is realized by z and z is an instance of Act which creates, modifies, transfers, or eliminates some u such that u is an Action Regulation at time t, and u is addressed to the bearer of y."@en

Added

• has subordinate role definition "For all x,y,t: x has subordinate role y at t iff: x is an instance of Role at time t, and y is an instance of Role at time t, and there is some z such that x is realized by z and z is an instance of Process which creates, modifies, transfers, or eliminates some u such that u is a Process Regulation at time t, and u is addressed to the bearer of y."@en

is permitted by http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/is_permitted_by

Removed

• is permitted by definition "y is_permitted_by x at t iff: x is an instance of Action Regulation at time t, and y is an instance of Act at time t, and x prescribes that some agent may be agent in y."@en

Added

• is permitted by definition "y is_permitted_by x at t iff: x is an instance of Process Regulation at time t, and y is an instance of Process at time t, and x prescribes that y may occur."@en

is prohibited by http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/is_prohibited_by

Removed

• is prohibited by definition "y is_prohibited_by y at t iff: x is an instance of Action Regulation at time t, and y is an instance of Act at time t, and x prescribes that some agent must not be agent in y."@en

Added

• is prohibited by definition "y is_prohibited_by y at t iff: x is an instance of Process Regulation at time t, and y is an instance of Process at time t, and x prescribes that y must not occur."@en

is required by http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/is_required_by

Removed

• is required by definition "y is_required_by x at t iff: x is an instance of Action Regulation at time t, and y is an instance of Act at time t, and x prescribes that some agent must be agent in y."@en

Added

• is required by definition "y is_required_by x at t iff: x is an instance of Process Regulation at time t, and y is an instance of Process at time t, and x prescribes that some that y must occur."@en

is subordinate role to http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/is_subordinate_role_to

Removed

• is subordinate role to definition "For all x,y,t: y is subordinate role to x at t iff: x is an instance of bfo:BFO_0000023 (Role) at time t, and y is an instance of bfo:BFO_0000023 (Role) at time t, and there is some z such that x is realized by z and z is an instance of Act which creates, modifies, transfers, or eliminates some u such that u is an Action Regulation at time t, and u is addressed to the bearer of y."@en

Added

• is subordinate role to definition "For all x,y,t: y is subordinate role to x at t iff: x is an instance of Role at time t, and y is an instance of Role at time t, and there is some z such that x is realized by z and z is an instance of Process which creates, modifies, transfers, or eliminates some u such that u is a Process Regulation at time t, and u is addressed to the bearer of y."@en

permits http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/permits

Removed

• permits definition "x permits y at t iff: x is an instance of Action Regulation at time t, and y is an instance of Act at time t, and x prescribes that some agent may be agent in y."@en

Added

• permits definition "x permits y at t iff: x is an instance of Process Regulation at time t, and y is an instance of Process at time t, and x prescribes that y may occur."@en

prohibits http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/prohibits

Removed

• prohibits definition "x prohibits y at t iff: x is an instance of Action Regulation at time t, and y is an instance of Act at time t, and x prescribes that some agent must not be agent in y."@en

Added

• prohibits definition "x prohibits y at t iff: x is an instance of Process Regulation at time t, and y is an instance of Process at time t, and x prescribes that some that y must not occur."@en

requires http://www.ontologyrepository.com/CommonCoreOntologies/requires

Removed

• requires definition "x requires y at t iff: x is an instance of Action Regulation at time t, and y is an instance of Act at time t, and x prescribes that some agent must be agent in y."@en

Added

• requires definition "x requires y at t iff: x is an instance of Process Regulation at time t, and y is an instance of Process at time t, and x prescribes that some that y must occur."@en