Files
ROCm/lib/Analysis/Allocation.cpp
SJW 4db99e0139 [Alloc] Enhanced SharedMem Allocation for mutually exclusive but aliased buffers (#337)
* [Alloc] Enhanced for mutually exclusive but aliased buffers

- Use disjoint alias analysis to minimize shared memory requirements

* * fix for allocation test

* * added test
* fixed mfma_enc printer

* * fixed test
2023-09-25 20:09:33 -05:00

646 lines
24 KiB
C++

#include "triton/Analysis/Allocation.h"
#include "mlir/Analysis/DataFlowFramework.h"
#include "mlir/Analysis/Liveness.h"
#include "mlir/Analysis/SliceAnalysis.h"
#include "mlir/Dialect/Tensor/IR/Tensor.h"
#include "triton/Analysis/Alias.h"
#include "triton/Dialect/TritonGPU/IR/Dialect.h"
#include "llvm/ADT/SmallVector.h"
#include <algorithm>
#include <limits>
#include <numeric>
using ::mlir::triton::gpu::BlockedEncodingAttr;
using ::mlir::triton::gpu::DotOperandEncodingAttr;
using ::mlir::triton::gpu::getContigPerThread;
using ::mlir::triton::gpu::getOrder;
using ::mlir::triton::gpu::getShapePerCTA;
using ::mlir::triton::gpu::getSizePerThread;
using ::mlir::triton::gpu::MfmaEncodingAttr;
using ::mlir::triton::gpu::MmaEncodingAttr;
using ::mlir::triton::gpu::SharedEncodingAttr;
using ::mlir::triton::gpu::SliceEncodingAttr;
namespace mlir {
//===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
// Shared Memory Allocation Analysis
//===----------------------------------------------------------------------===//
namespace triton {
// Bitwidth of pointers
constexpr int kPtrBitWidth = 64;
static std::pair<SmallVector<unsigned>, SmallVector<unsigned>>
getCvtOrder(Attribute srcLayout, Attribute dstLayout) {
auto srcMmaLayout = srcLayout.dyn_cast<MmaEncodingAttr>();
auto srcDotLayout = srcLayout.dyn_cast<DotOperandEncodingAttr>();
auto dstMmaLayout = dstLayout.dyn_cast<MmaEncodingAttr>();
auto dstDotLayout = dstLayout.dyn_cast<DotOperandEncodingAttr>();
assert(!(srcMmaLayout && dstMmaLayout) &&
"Unexpected mma -> mma layout conversion");
// mma or dot layout does not have an order, so the order depends on the
// layout of the other operand.
auto inOrd = (srcMmaLayout || srcDotLayout) ? getOrder(dstLayout)
: getOrder(srcLayout);
auto outOrd = (dstMmaLayout || dstDotLayout) ? getOrder(srcLayout)
: getOrder(dstLayout);
return {inOrd, outOrd};
}
SmallVector<unsigned>
getScratchConfigForCvtLayout(triton::gpu::ConvertLayoutOp op, unsigned &inVec,
unsigned &outVec) {
auto srcTy = op.getSrc().getType().cast<RankedTensorType>();
auto dstTy = op.getResult().getType().cast<RankedTensorType>();
Attribute srcLayout = srcTy.getEncoding();
Attribute dstLayout = dstTy.getEncoding();
// MmaToDotShortcut doesn't use shared mem
if (srcLayout.isa<MmaEncodingAttr>() &&
dstLayout.isa<DotOperandEncodingAttr>())
if (isMmaToDotShortcut(srcTy, dstTy))
return {};
#ifdef USE_ROCM
if (srcLayout.isa<MfmaEncodingAttr>() &&
srcLayout.dyn_cast<MfmaEncodingAttr>().getIsTransposed() &&
dstLayout.isa<DotOperandEncodingAttr>())
if (isMfmaToDotShortcut(srcTy, dstTy))
return {};
#endif
assert(srcLayout && dstLayout &&
"Unexpected layout in getScratchConfigForCvtLayout()");
auto [inOrd, outOrd] = getCvtOrder(srcLayout, dstLayout);
unsigned srcContigPerThread = getContigPerThread(srcLayout)[inOrd[0]];
unsigned dstContigPerThread = getContigPerThread(dstLayout)[outOrd[0]];
// TODO: Fix the legacy issue that ourOrd[0] == 0 always means
// that we cannot do vectorization.
inVec = outOrd[0] == 0 ? 1 : inOrd[0] == 0 ? 1 : srcContigPerThread;
outVec = outOrd[0] == 0 ? 1 : dstContigPerThread;
auto srcShape = srcTy.getShape();
auto dstShape = dstTy.getShape();
auto srcShapePerCTA = getShapePerCTA(srcLayout, srcShape);
auto dstShapePerCTA = getShapePerCTA(dstLayout, dstShape);
unsigned rank = dstTy.getRank();
SmallVector<unsigned> paddedRepShape(rank);
unsigned pad = std::max(inVec, outVec);
for (unsigned d = 0; d < rank; ++d) {
paddedRepShape[d] =
std::max(std::min<unsigned>(srcTy.getShape()[d], srcShapePerCTA[d]),
std::min<unsigned>(dstTy.getShape()[d], dstShapePerCTA[d]));
}
if (rank == 1)
return paddedRepShape;
unsigned paddedDim = 1;
if (auto dstBlockedLayout = dstLayout.dyn_cast<BlockedEncodingAttr>()) {
paddedDim = dstBlockedLayout.getOrder()[0];
}
paddedRepShape[paddedDim] += pad;
return paddedRepShape;
}
// TODO: extend beyond scalars
SmallVector<unsigned> getScratchConfigForAtomicRMW(triton::AtomicRMWOp op) {
SmallVector<unsigned> smemShape;
if (op.getPtr().getType().isa<RankedTensorType>()) {
// do nothing or just assert because shared memory is not used in tensor up
// to now
} else {
// need only bytes for scalar
// always vec = 1 and elemsPerThread = 1 for scalar?
smemShape.push_back(1);
}
return smemShape;
}
SmallVector<unsigned> getScratchConfigForAtomicCAS(triton::AtomicCASOp op) {
return SmallVector<unsigned>{1};
}
class AllocationAnalysis {
public:
AllocationAnalysis(Operation *operation,
Allocation::FuncAllocMapT *funcAllocMap,
Allocation *allocation)
: operation(operation), funcAllocMap(funcAllocMap),
allocation(allocation) {
run();
}
private:
using BufferT = Allocation::BufferT;
/// Value -> Liveness Range
using IntervalT = Interval<size_t>;
/// Use MapVector to ensure determinism.
using BufferRangeMapT = llvm::MapVector<BufferT *, IntervalT>;
/// Nodes -> Nodes
using GraphT = DenseMap<BufferT *, DenseSet<BufferT *>>;
/// Set of Liveness Intervals
class LivenessR : public SmallVector<IntervalT, 4> {
public:
LivenessR() = default;
LivenessR(const LivenessR &) = default;
/// Disjointness
bool isDisjoint() const {
if (size() < 2)
return false;
// sorted so the first OOB proves disjoint
auto maxId = (*this)[0].end();
for (auto rng : *this) {
if (rng.start() <= maxId) {
// adjoining
maxId = std::max(maxId, rng.end());
} else
return true;
}
return false;
}
void sort() {
llvm::sort(*this, [](const auto &lhs, const auto &rhs) {
return lhs.start() <= rhs.start();
});
}
bool addAdjacent(size_t id) {
bool isAdjacent = false;
for (auto &interval : *this) {
if (interval.adjacent(id)) {
isAdjacent = true;
interval = interval.merge(IntervalT(id));
}
}
return isAdjacent;
}
void add(size_t id) {
if (!addAdjacent(id))
push_back(IntervalT(id));
}
IntervalT unionize() const {
IntervalT res;
if (size()) {
res = front();
for (auto &I : *this)
res = res.merge(I);
}
return res;
}
};
typedef function_ref<LivenessR(Value value)> LivenessF;
void run() {
getValuesAndSizes();
resolveLiveness();
computeOffsets();
}
/// Initializes explicitly defined shared memory values for a given operation.
void getExplicitValueSize(Operation *op) {
// Values returned from scf.yield will not be allocated even though they
// have the shared encoding.
// For example: %a = scf.if -> yield
// %a must be allocated elsewhere by other operations.
// FIXME(Keren): extract and insert are always alias for now
if (!maybeSharedAllocationOp(op) || maybeAliasOp(op)) {
return;
}
for (Value result : op->getResults()) {
if (triton::gpu::isSharedEncoding(result)) {
// Bytes could be a different value once we support padding or other
// allocation policies.
auto tensorType = result.getType().dyn_cast<RankedTensorType>();
auto bytes = tensorType.getNumElements() *
tensorType.getElementTypeBitWidth() / 8;
allocation->addBuffer<BufferT::BufferKind::Explicit>(result, bytes);
}
}
}
template <BufferT::BufferKind T>
void maybeAddScratchBuffer(Operation *op, unsigned bytes) {
if (bytes > 0)
allocation->addBuffer<T>(op, bytes);
}
/// Initializes temporary shared memory for a given operation.
void getScratchValueSize(Operation *op) {
if (auto reduceOp = dyn_cast<triton::ReduceOp>(op)) {
ReduceOpHelper helper(reduceOp);
unsigned bytes = helper.getScratchSizeInBytes();
maybeAddScratchBuffer<BufferT::BufferKind::Scratch>(op, bytes);
} else if (auto scanOp = dyn_cast<triton::ScanOp>(op)) {
ScanLoweringHelper helper(scanOp);
unsigned bytes = helper.getScratchSizeInBytes();
maybeAddScratchBuffer<BufferT::BufferKind::Scratch>(op, bytes);
} else if (auto cvtLayout = dyn_cast<triton::gpu::ConvertLayoutOp>(op)) {
auto srcTy = cvtLayout.getSrc().getType().cast<RankedTensorType>();
auto dstTy = cvtLayout.getResult().getType().cast<RankedTensorType>();
auto srcEncoding = srcTy.getEncoding();
auto dstEncoding = dstTy.getEncoding();
if (srcEncoding.isa<SharedEncodingAttr>() ||
dstEncoding.isa<SharedEncodingAttr>()) {
// Conversions from/to shared memory do not need scratch memory.
return;
}
// ConvertLayoutOp with both input/output non-shared_layout
// TODO: Besides of implementing ConvertLayoutOp via shared memory, it's
// also possible to realize it with other approaches in restricted
// conditions, such as warp-shuffle
unsigned inVec = 0;
unsigned outVec = 0;
auto smemShape = getScratchConfigForCvtLayout(cvtLayout, inVec, outVec);
unsigned elems = std::accumulate(smemShape.begin(), smemShape.end(), 1,
std::multiplies{});
auto bytes =
srcTy.getElementType().isa<triton::PointerType>()
? elems * kPtrBitWidth / 8
: elems * std::max<int>(8, srcTy.getElementTypeBitWidth()) / 8;
maybeAddScratchBuffer<BufferT::BufferKind::Scratch>(op, bytes);
} else if (auto atomicRMWOp = dyn_cast<triton::AtomicRMWOp>(op)) {
auto value = op->getOperand(0);
// only scalar requires scratch memory
// make it explicit for readability
if (value.getType().dyn_cast<RankedTensorType>()) {
// nothing to do
} else {
auto smemShape = getScratchConfigForAtomicRMW(atomicRMWOp);
unsigned elems = std::accumulate(smemShape.begin(), smemShape.end(), 1,
std::multiplies{});
auto elemTy =
value.getType().cast<triton::PointerType>().getPointeeType();
auto bytes =
elemTy.isa<triton::PointerType>()
? elems * kPtrBitWidth / 8
: elems * std::max<int>(8, elemTy.getIntOrFloatBitWidth()) / 8;
maybeAddScratchBuffer<BufferT::BufferKind::Scratch>(op, bytes);
}
} else if (auto atomicCASOp = dyn_cast<triton::AtomicCASOp>(op)) {
auto value = op->getOperand(0);
auto smemShape = getScratchConfigForAtomicCAS(atomicCASOp);
unsigned elems = std::accumulate(smemShape.begin(), smemShape.end(), 1,
std::multiplies{});
auto elemTy =
value.getType().cast<triton::PointerType>().getPointeeType();
auto bytes = elemTy.isa<triton::PointerType>()
? elems * kPtrBitWidth / 8
: elems * elemTy.getIntOrFloatBitWidth() / 8;
maybeAddScratchBuffer<BufferT::BufferKind::Scratch>(op, bytes);
} else if (auto callOp = dyn_cast<CallOpInterface>(op)) {
auto callable = callOp.resolveCallable();
auto funcOp = dyn_cast<FunctionOpInterface>(callable);
auto *funcAlloc = &(*funcAllocMap)[funcOp];
auto bytes = funcAlloc->getSharedMemorySize();
maybeAddScratchBuffer<BufferT::BufferKind::Virtual>(op, bytes);
}
}
void getValueAlias(Value value, SharedMemoryAliasAnalysis &analysis) {
dataflow::Lattice<AliasInfo> *latticeElement =
analysis.getLatticeElement(value);
if (latticeElement) {
AliasInfo &info = latticeElement->getValue();
if (!info.getAllocs().empty()) {
for (auto alloc : info.getAllocs()) {
allocation->addAlias(value, alloc);
}
}
}
}
/// Extract all shared memory values and their sizes
void getValuesAndSizes() {
// Get the alloc values
operation->walk<WalkOrder::PreOrder>([&](Operation *op) {
getExplicitValueSize(op);
getScratchValueSize(op);
});
// Get the alias values
std::unique_ptr<DataFlowSolver> solver = createDataFlowSolver();
SharedMemoryAliasAnalysis *aliasAnalysis =
solver->load<SharedMemoryAliasAnalysis>();
if (failed(solver->initializeAndRun(operation))) {
// TODO: return error instead of bailing out..
llvm_unreachable("failed to run SharedMemoryAliasAnalysis");
}
operation->walk<WalkOrder::PreOrder>([&](Operation *op) {
for (auto operand : op->getOperands()) {
getValueAlias(operand, *aliasAnalysis);
}
for (auto value : op->getResults()) {
getValueAlias(value, *aliasAnalysis);
}
});
}
/// Computes the liveness range of the allocated value.
/// Each buffer is allocated only once.
void resolveExplicitBufferLiveness(LivenessF getLiveness) {
for (auto valueBufferIter : allocation->valueBuffer) {
auto value = valueBufferIter.first;
auto *buffer = valueBufferIter.second;
auto ranges = getLiveness(value);
bufferRange[buffer] = ranges.unionize();
}
}
/// Extends the liveness range by unionizing the liveness range of the aliased
/// values because each allocated buffer could be an alias of others, if block
/// arguments are involved.
/// Only unionize adjacent live ranges to account for loop-carried buffers that
/// are mutually exclusive.
/// Example from stream pipeliner:
/// 3 %b0 = convert_layout %g0 -+
/// 4 %fr = for (.., %arg0 = %b0) { |
/// 5 %gn = load %pc |
/// 6 %bc = convert_layout %arg0 -+
/// 7 %v = add %bc, ...
/// 8 %bn = convert_layout %gn -+
/// 9 %pn = addptr %pc, %cst |
/// 10 } |
/// 11 %be = convert_layout %fr#1 -+
/// 12 %ve = add %be
void resolveAliasBufferLiveness(LivenessF getLiveness) {
for (auto aliasBufferIter : allocation->aliasBuffer) {
auto value = aliasBufferIter.first;
auto buffers = aliasBufferIter.second;
auto aranges = getLiveness(value);
bool disjoint = aranges.isDisjoint();
for (auto *buffer : buffers) {
auto range = aranges[0];
if (bufferRange.count(buffer)) {
auto brange = bufferRange[buffer];
if (disjoint) {
// find adjacent/intersecting
for (auto arange : aranges) {
if (arange.adjacent(brange) ||
arange.intersects(brange))
brange = arange.merge(brange);
}
range = brange;
} else {
// Extend the allocated buffer's range
range = range.merge(brange);
}
}
bufferRange[buffer] = range;
}
}
}
/// Computes the liveness range of scratched buffers.
/// Some operations may have a temporary buffer that is not explicitly
/// allocated, but is used to store intermediate results.
void resolveScratchBufferLiveness(
const DenseMap<Operation *, size_t> &operationId) {
// Analyze liveness of scratch buffers and vritual buffers.
auto processScratchMemory = [&](const auto &container) {
for (auto opScratchIter : container) {
// Any scratch memory's live range is the current operation's live
// range.
auto *op = opScratchIter.first;
auto *buffer = opScratchIter.second;
bufferRange.insert({buffer, Interval(operationId.lookup(op),
operationId.lookup(op) + 1)});
}
};
processScratchMemory(allocation->opScratch);
processScratchMemory(allocation->opVirtual);
}
/// Resolves liveness of all values involved under the root operation.
void resolveLiveness() {
// Assign an ID to each operation using post-order traversal.
// To achieve the correct liveness range, the parent operation's ID
// should be greater than each of its child operation's ID .
// Example:
// ...
// %5 = triton.convert_layout %4
// %6 = scf.for ... iter_args(%arg0 = %0) -> (i32) {
// %2 = triton.convert_layout %5
// ...
// scf.yield %arg0
// }
// For example, %5 is defined in the parent region and used in
// the child region, and is not passed as a block argument.
// %6 should should have an ID greater than its child operations,
// otherwise %5 liveness range ends before the child operation's liveness
// range ends.
DenseMap<Operation *, size_t> operationId;
operation->walk<WalkOrder::PostOrder>(
[&](Operation *op) { operationId[op] = operationId.size(); });
// Analyze liveness of explicit buffers
Liveness liveness(operation);
auto getValueLivenessRange = [&](Value value) {
auto liveOperations = liveness.resolveLiveness(value);
LivenessR ranges;
std::for_each(liveOperations.begin(), liveOperations.end(),
[&](Operation *liveOp) {
ranges.add(operationId[liveOp]);
});
ranges.sort();
return ranges;
};
resolveExplicitBufferLiveness(getValueLivenessRange);
resolveAliasBufferLiveness(getValueLivenessRange);
resolveScratchBufferLiveness(operationId);
}
/// Computes the shared memory offsets for all related values.
/// Paper: Algorithms for Compile-Time Memory Optimization
/// (https://www.cs.utexas.edu/users/harrison/papers/compile-time.pdf)
void computeOffsets() {
SmallVector<BufferT *> buffers;
for (auto bufferIter : bufferRange) {
buffers.emplace_back(bufferIter.first);
}
DenseMap<BufferT *, size_t> bufferStart;
calculateStarts(buffers, bufferStart);
// NOTE: The original paper doesn't consider interference between
// the bumped ranges. Buffers that previously do not interfere with
// could interfere after offset bumping if their liveness ranges overlap.
// Therefore, we rerun the interference graph algorithm after bumping so
// that we regroup the buffers and color them again. Since we always
// increase the buffer offset and keep reducing conflicts, we will
// eventually reach a fixed point.
GraphT interference;
buildInterferenceGraph(buffers, bufferStart, interference);
do {
allocate(buffers, interference, bufferStart);
buildInterferenceGraph(buffers, bufferStart, interference);
} while (!interference.empty());
}
/// Computes the initial shared memory offsets.
void calculateStarts(const SmallVector<BufferT *> &buffers,
DenseMap<BufferT *, size_t> &bufferStart) {
// v = values in shared memory
// t = triplet of (size, start, end)
// shared memory space
// -
// | *******t4
// | /|\ v2 inserts t4, t5, and t6
// | |
// | ******t5 ************t6
// | ^^^^^v2^^^^^^
// | | *********************t2
// | \|/ v2 erases t1
// | ******t1 ^^^^^^^^^v1^^^^^^^^^ ************t3
// |---------------------------------------------| liveness range
// 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 ...
// If the available triple's range is less than a given buffer range,
// we won't know if there has been an overlap without using graph coloring.
// Start -> Liveness Range
using TripleMapT = std::multimap<size_t, IntervalT>;
TripleMapT tripleMap;
tripleMap.insert(std::make_pair(0, IntervalT()));
SmallVector<BufferT *> xBuffers = buffers;
while (!xBuffers.empty()) {
auto tripleIt = tripleMap.begin();
auto size = tripleIt->first;
auto range = tripleIt->second;
tripleMap.erase(tripleIt);
auto bufferIt =
std::find_if(xBuffers.begin(), xBuffers.end(), [&](auto *buffer) {
auto xRange = bufferRange[buffer];
bool res = xRange.intersects(range);
for (auto val : tripleMap)
res = res && !val.second.intersects(xRange);
return res;
});
if (bufferIt != xBuffers.end()) {
auto buffer = *bufferIt;
auto xSize = buffer->size;
auto xRange = bufferRange.lookup(buffer);
bufferStart[buffer] = size;
tripleMap.insert(
{size + xSize, Interval{std::max(range.start(), xRange.start()),
std::min(range.end(), xRange.end())}});
// We could either insert (range.start, xRange.start) or (range.start,
// xRange.end), both are correct and determine the potential buffer
// offset, and the graph coloring algorithm will solve the interference,
// if any
if (range.start() < xRange.start())
tripleMap.insert({size, Interval{range.start(), xRange.end()}});
if (xRange.end() < range.end())
tripleMap.insert({size, Interval{xRange.start(), range.end()}});
xBuffers.erase(bufferIt);
}
}
}
/// Builds a graph of all shared memory values. Edges are created between
/// shared memory values that are overlapping.
void buildInterferenceGraph(const SmallVector<BufferT *> &buffers,
const DenseMap<BufferT *, size_t> &bufferStart,
GraphT &interference) {
// Reset interference graph
interference.clear();
for (auto x : buffers) {
for (auto y : buffers) {
if (x == y)
continue;
auto xStart = bufferStart.lookup(x);
auto yStart = bufferStart.lookup(y);
auto xSize = x->size;
auto ySize = y->size;
Interval xSizeRange = {xStart, xStart + xSize};
Interval ySizeRange = {yStart, yStart + ySize};
auto xOpRange = bufferRange.lookup(x);
auto yOpRange = bufferRange.lookup(y);
if (xOpRange.intersects(yOpRange) &&
xSizeRange.intersects(ySizeRange)) {
interference[x].insert(y);
}
}
}
}
/// Finalizes shared memory offsets considering interference.
void allocate(const SmallVector<BufferT *> &buffers,
const GraphT &interference,
DenseMap<BufferT *, size_t> &bufferStart) {
// Reset shared memory size
allocation->sharedMemorySize = 0;
// First-fit graph coloring
// Neighbors are nodes that interfere with each other.
// We color a node by finding the index of the first available
// non-neighboring node or the first neighboring node without any color.
// Nodes with the same color do not interfere with each other.
DenseMap<BufferT *, int> colors;
for (auto value : buffers) {
colors[value] = (value == buffers[0]) ? 0 : -1;
}
SmallVector<bool> available(buffers.size());
for (auto x : buffers) {
std::fill(available.begin(), available.end(), true);
for (auto y : interference.lookup(x)) {
int color = colors[y];
if (color >= 0) {
available[color] = false;
}
}
auto it = std::find(available.begin(), available.end(), true);
colors[x] = std::distance(available.begin(), it);
}
// Finalize allocation
// color0: [0, 7), [0, 8), [0, 15) -> [0, 7), [0, 8), [0, 15)
// color1: [7, 9) -> [0 + 1 * 15, 9 + 1 * 15) -> [15, 24)
// color2: [8, 12) -> [8 + 2 * 15, 12 + 2 * 15) -> [38, 42)
// TODO(Keren): We are wasting memory here.
// Nodes with color2 can actually start with 24.
for (auto x : buffers) {
size_t adj = 0;
for (auto y : interference.lookup(x)) {
adj = std::max(adj, bufferStart.lookup(y) + y->size);
}
x->offset = bufferStart.lookup(x) + colors.lookup(x) * adj;
bufferStart[x] = x->offset;
allocation->sharedMemorySize =
std::max(allocation->sharedMemorySize, x->offset + x->size);
}
}
void dump() const {
llvm::outs() << "DUMP: " << "\n";
for (auto bufferIter : bufferRange) {
llvm::outs() << "ID= " << bufferIter.first->id << "\n";
// llvm::outs() << " Kind= " << kind << "\n";
llvm::outs() << " Size= " << bufferIter.first->size << "\n";
llvm::outs() << " Offs= " << bufferIter.first->offset << "\n";
llvm::outs() << " -> " << bufferIter.second.start() << "\n";
llvm::outs() << " -> " << bufferIter.second.end() << "\n";
}
}
private:
Operation *operation;
Allocation::FuncAllocMapT *funcAllocMap;
Allocation *allocation;
BufferRangeMapT bufferRange;
};
} // namespace triton
void Allocation::run(FuncAllocMapT &funcAllocMap) {
triton::AllocationAnalysis(getOperation(), &funcAllocMap, this);
}
} // namespace mlir