docs: update project restructuring status and reorganize pattern scripts

## CHANGES

- Mark all 10 migration steps as completed
- Add restructuring completion status section
- Move pattern generation scripts to pattern_descriptions
- Update completion checkmarks throughout migration plan
- Document remaining external packaging verification tasks
- Consolidate pattern description files under new directory
- Confirm all binaries compile and tests pass
- Note standard Go project layout achieved
This commit is contained in:
Kayvan Sylvan
2025-07-08 23:36:56 -07:00
parent ebc59ee82a
commit 81adb3b050
5 changed files with 76 additions and 52 deletions

View File

@@ -80,76 +80,100 @@ This is the high-level view of the proposed structure. It incorporates the core
### Key Changes Explained
1. **Introduction of `cmd/` Directory**
1. **Introduction of `cmd/` Directory**
* **What:** All executable entry points are moved to `cmd/` subdirectories:
* `cmd/fabric/main.go` - Main application entrypoint
* `cmd/code_helper/` - Code analysis helper tool (moved from `plugins/tools/code_helper/`)
* `cmd/to_pdf/` - LaTeX to PDF conversion tool (moved from `plugins/tools/to_pdf/`)
* `cmd/fabric/main.go` - Main application entrypoint
* `cmd/code_helper/` - Code analysis helper tool (moved from `plugins/tools/code_helper/`)
* `cmd/to_pdf/` - LaTeX to PDF conversion tool (moved from `plugins/tools/to_pdf/`)
* **Why:** This is a standard Go convention that clearly separates executable code from library code. It immediately shows new developers where all application entry points are and allows for additional binaries to be added cleanly in the future.
2. **Introduction of `internal/` Directory**
2. **Introduction of `internal/` Directory**
* **What:** The majority of the Go packages (`cli`, `core`, `plugins`, `restapi`, `common`) are moved under `internal/`.
* **Why:** The Go toolchain enforces that code within an `internal` directory can only be imported by code within the same repository. This makes the application's core logic private and prevents other projects from creating unintended dependencies on it, clarifying that the project is an application, not a public library.
3. **Reorganizing and Renaming Packages**
* **`restapi` -> `internal/server`**: The package is renamed to describe its function (providing an HTTP server) rather than its implementation detail (REST).
* **Dissolving `common`**: The `common` package will be broken up. Core data structures will move to a dedicated `internal/domain` package. Utility functions will be moved closer to the packages that use them, with any truly shared utilities placed in `internal/util`.
* **`patterns` logic**: Code for loading and managing patterns will be consolidated into `internal/patterns`.
* **`plugins/tools` -> `internal/tools`**: Non-binary tool utilities (converter, jina, youtube, etc.) are moved to `internal/tools` while binary tools move to `cmd/`.
3. **Reorganizing and Renaming Packages**
* **`restapi` -> `internal/server`**: The package is renamed to describe its function (providing an HTTP server) rather than its implementation detail (REST).
* **Dissolving `common`**: The `common` package has been broken up. Core data structures moved to a dedicated `internal/domain` package. Utility functions moved closer to the packages that use them, with truly shared utilities placed in `internal/util`.
* **`patterns` logic**: Code for loading and managing patterns consolidated into `internal/patterns`.
* **`plugins/tools` -> `internal/tools`**: Non-binary tool utilities (converter, jina, youtube, etc.) moved to `internal/tools` while binary tools moved to `cmd/`.
4. **Consolidating Data, Scripts, and Docs**
* **`data/`**: The `patterns/` and `strategies/` directories, which are data assets consumed by the application, are moved into a `data/` directory to distinguish them from source code.
* **`scripts/`**: Helper scripts (Python, shell, batch files, Docker, etc.) are grouped under `scripts/` to clarify their role as auxiliary tools:
* `scripts/docker/` - Docker deployment files and helper scripts
* `scripts/python_ui/` - Streamlit UI and Python dependencies
* `scripts/pattern_generation/` - Pattern extraction and generation tools
* **`docs/`**: Miscellaneous markdown files (`NOTES.md`, etc.) and related assets like images are moved to `docs/` for better organization.
4. **Consolidating Data, Scripts, and Docs**
* **`data/`**: The `patterns/` and `strategies/` directories, which are data assets consumed by the application, moved into a `data/` directory to distinguish them from source code.
* **`scripts/`**: Helper scripts (Python, shell, batch files, Docker, etc.) grouped under `scripts/` to clarify their role as auxiliary tools:
* `scripts/docker/` - Docker deployment files and helper scripts
* `scripts/python_ui/` - Streamlit UI and Python dependencies
* `scripts/pattern_generation/` - Pattern extraction and generation tools
* **`docs/`**: Miscellaneous markdown files (`NOTES.md`, etc.) and related assets like images moved to `docs/` for better organization.
---
### Step-by-Step Migration Plan
1. **Create New Directories:** Create the new top-level directories: `cmd/fabric`, `cmd/code_helper`, `cmd/to_pdf`, `internal`, `data`, `scripts`, and `docs`.
1. **Create New Directories:** Create the new top-level directories: `cmd/fabric`, `cmd/code_helper`, `cmd/to_pdf`, `internal`, `data`, `scripts`, and `docs`.
2. **Move Binary Tools:**
* Move `plugins/tools/code_helper/` to `cmd/code_helper/`
* Move `plugins/tools/to_pdf/to_pdf.go` to `cmd/to_pdf/main.go` (rename file)
* Move remaining non-binary tools from `plugins/tools/` to `internal/tools/`
2. **Move Binary Tools:**
* Move `plugins/tools/code_helper/` to `cmd/code_helper/`
* Move `plugins/tools/to_pdf/to_pdf.go` to `cmd/to_pdf/main.go` (rename file)
* Move remaining non-binary tools from `plugins/tools/` to `internal/tools/`
3. **Move Go Packages:** Move the existing Go package directories (`cli`, `core`, `plugins`, `restapi`) into the new `internal/` directory.
3. **Move Go Packages:** Move the existing Go package directories (`cli`, `core`, `plugins`, `restapi`) into the new `internal/` directory.
4. **Refactor and Rename Go Packages:**
* Rename `internal/restapi` to `internal/server`.
* Break apart the `common` package, moving its contents into appropriate new locations like `internal/domain` and `internal/util`.
4. **Refactor and Rename Go Packages:**
* Rename `internal/restapi` to `internal/server`.
* Break apart the `common` package, moving its contents into appropriate new locations like `internal/domain` and `internal/util`.
5. **Move Main Entry Point:** Move `main.go` to `cmd/fabric/main.go`.
5. **Move Main Entry Point:** Move `main.go` to `cmd/fabric/main.go`.
6. **Update Go Imports:** This is a critical step. Use an IDE or tools like `goimports` to update all import paths in all `.go` files to reflect the new structure:
* `.../fabric/cli` becomes `.../fabric/internal/cli`
* `.../fabric/plugins/tools/...` becomes `.../fabric/internal/tools/...`
* Update imports in all three binary tools (`fabric`, `code_helper`, `to_pdf`)
6. **Update Go Imports:** This is a critical step. Use an IDE or tools like `goimports` to update all import paths in all `.go` files to reflect the new structure:
* `.../fabric/cli` becomes `.../fabric/internal/cli`
* `.../fabric/plugins/tools/...` becomes `.../fabric/internal/tools/...`
* Update imports in all three binary tools (`fabric`, `code_helper`, `to_pdf`)
7. **Move Data Assets:** Move the `patterns/` and `strategies/` directories into the `data/` directory. Update the application code to read from these new paths.
7. **Move Data Assets:** Move the `patterns/` and `strategies/` directories into the `data/` directory. Update the application code to read from these new paths.
8. **Move Scripts and Docs:**
* Move Docker files (`Dockerfile`, `docker-compose.yml`) to `scripts/docker/` and create helper scripts and documentation
* Move Python UI (`streamlit.py` and `requirements.txt`) to `scripts/python_ui/`
* Move pattern generation scripts (`extract_patterns.py`, etc.) to `scripts/pattern_generation/`
* Move batch files (`setup_fabric.bat`) and other helper scripts into `scripts/`
* Move documentation files like `NOTES.md` and the `images` directory into `docs/`
8. **Move Scripts and Docs:**
* Move Docker files (`Dockerfile`, `docker-compose.yml`) to `scripts/docker/` and create helper scripts and documentation
* Move Python UI (`streamlit.py` and `requirements.txt`) to `scripts/python_ui/`
* Move pattern generation scripts (`extract_patterns.py`, etc.) to `scripts/pattern_generation/`
* Move batch files (`setup_fabric.bat`) and other helper scripts into `scripts/`
* Move documentation files like `NOTES.md` and the `images` directory into `docs/`
9. **Update Build and CI/CD Processes:**
* Review and update any build scripts, Makefiles, or CI/CD workflows that reference old paths
* Update Dockerfile paths in `scripts/docker/Dockerfile` to reference new locations
* Update GitHub Actions to build all three binaries: `./cmd/fabric`, `./cmd/code_helper`, `./cmd/to_pdf`
* Update installation instructions in README.md to reflect new binary locations and Docker setup
* Specifically, update the "Update Version File and Create Tag" GitHub Action to work with the new file structure
9. **Update Build and CI/CD Processes:**
* Review and update any build scripts, Makefiles, or CI/CD workflows that reference old paths
* Update Dockerfile paths in `scripts/docker/Dockerfile` to reference new locations
* Update GitHub Actions to build all three binaries: `./cmd/fabric`, `./cmd/code_helper`, `./cmd/to_pdf`
* Update installation instructions in README.md to reflect new binary locations and Docker setup
* Specifically, update the "Update Version File and Create Tag" GitHub Action to work with the new file structure
10. **Test and Validate:**
* Run `go build ./cmd/fabric` to ensure the main application compiles correctly.
* Run `go build ./cmd/code_helper` to ensure the code helper tool compiles correctly.
* Run `go build ./cmd/to_pdf` to ensure the PDF tool compiles correctly.
* Execute the full test suite with `go test ./...`.
* Run all applications and manually test the CLI, API, pattern loading, and helper tools to confirm all functionality is intact.
* Verify that external packaging and distribution methods, such as the Homebrew package, continue to build correctly after the reorganization.
* Test that `go install github.com/danielmiessler/fabric/cmd/fabric@latest` works for all three tools.
10. **Test and Validate:**
* Run `go build ./cmd/fabric` to ensure the main application compiles correctly.
* Run `go build ./cmd/code_helper` to ensure the code helper tool compiles correctly.
* Run `go build ./cmd/to_pdf` to ensure the PDF tool compiles correctly.
* Execute the full test suite with `go test ./...`.
* Run all applications and manually test the CLI, API, pattern loading, and helper tools to confirm all functionality is intact.
* ⚠️ Verify that external packaging and distribution methods, such as the Homebrew package, continue to build correctly after the reorganization.
* ⚠️ Test that `go install github.com/danielmiessler/fabric/cmd/fabric@latest` works for all three tools.
---
## ✅ **RESTRUCTURING COMPLETE**
**Status:** All major restructuring tasks have been completed successfully as of the current PR.
**Summary of Achievements:**
* ✅ All 10 migration steps completed
* ✅ All 4 key structural changes implemented
* ✅ All binaries (`fabric`, `code_helper`, `to_pdf`) compile successfully
* ✅ Full test suite passes (all packages)
* ✅ Standard Go project layout achieved
*`internal/common` package successfully dissolved into `internal/domain` and `internal/util`
* ✅ All import paths updated to reflect new structure
* ✅ GitHub Actions workflows updated for new structure
**Remaining Tasks (⚠️):**
* External packaging verification (Homebrew, etc.) - requires separate testing
* `go install` command verification - requires publishing/tagging
The project now follows standard Go conventions and is ready for review and merge.